Behavior and Training · dog-human relationship · Health · Nutrition · Podcast Episodes · Science · science dog courses

Wait. You Can Eat THAT?

Poop eating.  Lots of dogs do it.

Many are quite proud of it.

Owners? Generally not so enthusiastic.


What do they eat? The technical term for poop-eating, of any type, is coprophagy. Many dogs readily consume the feces of other animal species – rabbit, deer, horse, possum and raccoon. Additionally, dogs who share their home with a cat often find poop of the feline variety to be especially tasty.


Lucky for us all, a smaller proportion of dogs consume the excrement of other dogs (called conspecific coprophagy). It is these dogs that we are looking at today.

Yes, this is an intervention. It is time.

ALICE CASE.
ADMITTED POOP EATER AND POOP ROLLER.
NOTICE THE POOP NECKLACE.

Believe it or not, there is some science on this topic – a few actual studies, even. Let’s review what we currently know about the dogs who eat canine feces, why they may do this, and how to best prevent or manage this unsavory behavior.

Lots of dogs do it…..

Coprophagy is considered to be a normal behavior in mother dogs. For the first several weeks after her pups are born, the mother ingests all of her pups’ feces. She does this for hygiene purposes to keep her puppies and the whelping area clean, and also because the associated licking and cleaning of the puppy provides needed stimulation for elimination. Mothers typically stop this after 2 to 3 weeks, once the puppies are starting to walk and can urinate and defecate without aid.

Stool eating is also relatively common in other adult dogs. A recently published survey study asked dog owners a series of questions regarding conspecific coprophagy (1). The researchers received almost 1500 responses. (Clearly, this was something dog owners wanted to get off of their chests). The results showed that between 16 and 23% of dogs either occasionally or frequently consumed the feces of other dogs. The dogs who showed frequent coprophagy were more likely to live in multiple dog homes than dogs who did not coprophagize (more about this in a bit).

Results also showed that in addition to being a commonly reported behavior, the majority of poop-eating dogs (82 %) directed their attention to poops that were fresh – no more than two days old. Add that to the yuck factor for owners.

For the researchers however, this fact was a significant one. Most intestinal parasites need to remain in the environment for several days or longer before becoming infective. This fact suggests that coprophagy has been selected for during the dog’s evolutionary history. Rapid consumption of recently voided feces would reduce the risk of infection with intestinal parasites. The researchers suggested that this tendency provides support for the “poop eating is a normal dog behavior” theory.

Finally, evidence from this study dispelled several prevalent poop-eating myths. Coprophagy was not associated with a dog’s sex, neuter status or age. Nor were early weaning, late or difficult housetraining, or compulsive-like behavior problems associated with a dog’s chance of developing a poop eating habit. Finally, this study, and others, dispelled one of the most prevalent myths about poop eating – a dog’s diet.

Diet and Poop Eating

Despite the many diet/nutrient-related beliefs about poop-eating in dogs, there is no scientific evidence that suggests dogs consume feces because of a particular nutrient deficiency or because they are fed a specific type of food.

So, when Joe Next Door (who happens to know a lot about dog poop) tells you that your dog consumes poop because: (a) you feed a certain brand of dog food; (b) you feed a food with too much carbohydrate; (c) you feed a food with too little carbohydrate; or (d) your dog is expressing a deficiency in [pick a nutrient that Joe can pronounce], feel free to tell Joe that he is full of…… dog poop. No studies to date have found an association between dogs’ diets and their propensity to develop coprophagy. Sorry Joe.

There is one diet-related behavior that correlates with coprophagy, however. Dogs who are reportedly “greedy” or rapid eaters are more likely to also enjoy eating feces. This observation suggests that dogs who experience higher levels of hunger may be more inclined to coprophagize. However, a pair of studies that followed the behavior of a group of dogs that initially had food available at all times and were switched to restricted meal feeding reported no difference in stool eating when the dogs were fed less food (2,3). This suggests that hunger may not be an underlying cause of the greedy eater connection.

Wait. You can eat that??

As noted above, the survey study found that dogs who frequently consume the feces of other dogs are more likely to live in a multiple dog home. Of course, this might simply reflect increased opportunity (i.e. more poop = more poop eating). A second set of researchers took a deeper look at this connection. They conducted in person and written interviews with the owners of 70 dogs; 30 dogs were identified as conspecific coprophagizers and 40 dogs refrained from eating feces.

Similar to the larger survey study, no associations were found between coprophagy and a dog’s sex, reproductive status, living situation or type or diet. However, poop eating was significantly more likely in homes that not only had another dog, but had another dog who also engaged in coprophagy. This should really not be surprising, given what we now understand about observational learning in dogs (they are very good at it). Dogs not only follow the attention of other dogs and will investigate items their friends are interested in, they also are capable of learning new behaviors from each other through observation (see “Doggy See, Doggy Do?). So, coprophagy may be learned from housemates. (Friends don’t let friends poop eat alone).

On a personal level, I rather suspected this. Our very first Golden, Fauna, was an intermittent poop eater. She apparently introduced this habit to one of her younger sisters, Roxie. Roxie then passed it along to Sparks, who gladly handed the torch over to Gusto, who mentored Cadie…….and onward. Today, we have Alice, who offers tutoring services to anyone who is interested. Lucky for us, neither Cooper nor Stanley have apparently yet taken her up on this generous offer.

ALICE (pink harness), ALWAYS HAPPY TO MENTOR HER TWO BROTHERS, COOP AND STANLEY

Normal behavior

It is now clear that a substantial number of healthy adult dogs indulge in the occasional poop treat. The general consensus is that coprophagy is a normal canine behavior, not an aberration. Its functional history is probably related to hygiene, parasite prevention, and possibly to scavenging behavior. This does not mean that owners of poop-eaters must accept this or allow it to continue. Rather, it means that there are probably no underlying health or behavioral issues in dogs who coprophagize and that it should be treated as a normal canine behavior that can be modified through management (mostly) and behavior modification (somewhat).

Before we look at what can help, let’s review what the science currently tells us doe NOT work.

Unsuccessful Remedies

  • Commercial supplements: There are a lot of these. They contain a lot of things. Some claim to either change the taste of feces, making it unpleasant to consume or to alter fecal odor. Others profess to contain nutrients that are lacking in the dog’s diet and that, once provided will magically stop the poop-eating. None provide controlled studies demonstrating efficacy. Owners who try these products report a reduction in poop-eating in less than 2 percent of cases. Save your pennies.
  • Reducing carbs: This is a popular one. Although an early study suggested that a high carbohydrate diet may increase a dog’s tendency to eat stools, there is no research evidence to date showing that reducing carbohydrate in a food reduces coprophagy in dogs. Yeesh. Carbs get blamed for everything these days.
  • Reducing boredom: Well, this is always a good thing to do, of course. Increasing play, exercise, and opportunities for owner interactions are all good things for our dogs. However, the only data that are available show that providing different types of toys to kenneled dogs as an attempt to relieve boredom did not reduce coprophagy. (But really, do all of this stuff with your dog anyway).
  • Punishment: In the large survey study, some owners used an electronic collar or other aversive in an attempt to punish coprophagy. Similar to the use of supplements, attempting to punish coprophagy had an abysmal success rate – less than 2 %. Please, do not do this. It does not work and it is not a nice thing to do to your dog.

Take Away for Dog Folks

There are several important points to take away from these recent reseach studies and the evidence that they provide:

  • Coprophagy is a normal dog behavior, exhibited by many healthy adult dogs, in different living situations that are fed a wide variety of foods. Some dogs eat poop. We need to accept this and move on.
  • Dogs pay attention to what their friends are eating. If you have a dog who eats poop, it is likely you will have more. Sorry.
  • Poop eating is resistant to change. Diet supplements do not work. Punishment does not work and is a bad thing to do anyway.
  • What can you do? Pick up your yard frequently. Supervise your dog. Reduce or completely prevent access to feces. Train a solid “Leave it” response using reward-based methods. This means that your dog learns that you consistently have a yummy treat that is much more attractive to her than the poop she is considering consuming (com’on now, its not a high bar to clear).
  • Enjoy your dog. Spend time, have fun together. Train that “Leave it” and chill a bit. Yeah, he might eat poop. But then, you probably do a few things that your dog finds annoying too.

ALICE. CLEAN (FOR NOW)
NOTHING A BATH AND A WELL-TRAINED “LEAVE IT” CANNOT HELP WITH

NEW! Listen to an audio version of this Science Dog essay on The Science Dog Podcast!


Cited Studies:

  1. Hart B, Hart L, Thigpen AP, Tran A, Bain M. The paradox of canine conspecific coprophagy. Veterinary Medicine and Science 2018; 4:106-114.
  2. Crowell-Davis SL, Barry K, Ballam JM, Laflamme DP. The effect of caloric restriction on the behavior of pen-housed dogs: Transition from unrestricted to restricted diet. Applied Animal Behavior Science 1995; 43:27-41.
  3. Crowell-Davis SL, Barry K, Ballam JM, Laflamme DP. The effect of caloric restriction on the behavior of pen-housed dogs: Transition from restriction to maintenance diets and long-term effects. Applied Animal Behavior Science 1995; 43:43-61.
  4. Amaral AR, Porsani MY, Martins PO, Teixeira FA, et al. Canine coprophagic behavior is influenced by coprophagic cohabitant. Journal of Veterinary Behavior 2018; 28:35-39.

Interested in Canine Nutrition?

Earn Your Masters Class Certificate in Canine Nutrition
with The Science Dog Courses
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is master-class-certificate-canine-nutrition-.jpg

Check Out ALL of The Science Dog Courses!

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is science-dog-courses-banner.jpg

16 thoughts on “Wait. You Can Eat THAT?

  1. I enjoy reading your posts. Lots of great science and I love your sense of humor. Many years ago (almost 30) I had two females (German shepherd mix and a husky) that stopped eating poop when I changed their food. I don’t have a speculation as to why but was very happy when it happened. I have two males now (German shepherd and a German shorthair). The German shorthair has been a driven poop eater since the first winter after I got him. He came to me in July (10 yrs ago) and didn’t start eating poop until after the weather turned cold and it snowed. I’ve tried a few different foods, but I use management and training consistently. He will eat his own and anyone and everyone else’s at every opportunity. However, I’ve noticed a couple of things with him. I had 2 girls when I first got him, they were all getting kibble and when I fed him or the girls real meat, he was even more driven to eat everyone’s poop. He would follow my 2 girls (who passed away in the last few of years) around closely, waiting for them to go. He once tried to catch it before it hit the ground. Ugh! Because he would get cold easily, I started adding a tablespoon of natural (no sugar) peanut butter consistently to his food to increase his fat intake, and noticed he was less driven about eating it. He is careful about eating my male German shepherd’s poop because the GSD doesn’t like to share anything (even if he’s never wanted it before!) and started a fight over it the first time the GSP tried to eat it. So he very cautious now and will wait until the GDS has moved away and no longer paying attention. I have Celiac Disease and added pineapple to my own diet some time ago because of the bromelain in it so about a year ago, just to experiment, I started adding it to his food (and continued with the peanut butter) and immediately noticed that he seemed to no longer even notice poop. He could walk right past it and not even notice it was there! Before the pineapple, watching for poopers and seeking out poop seemed to be his only interest! He was like a nose work dog and I definitely tell when he was ‘in order’! Unfortunately, I ran out of pineapple for a couple of days some time back and he went right back to noticing and checking out the spot where he went even though I am more careful not to run out and am still adding it and peanut better to his food. But I’m grateful for the almost a year that he interest was reduced.

    My GSD will eat only his own, not anyone else’s and seems to only do it when he’s stressed in certain ways. He seems to get stressed when if I don’t feed him at a consistent time. If I’m late feeding his evening meal, he’ll eat his poop, but not if I’m late with his morning meal. When he eats grass, has trouble going and gets what I call danglers :), he’ll turn immediately around and eat it once he’s done.

    My theory is that each dog has it’s own reasons for eating poop and it may involve more than one factor. Sorry for the long comment. I just think it’s such an interesting topic and love to talk about behavior, poop eating and otherwise.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Oh no! Grammar police here! The term, “general consensus” is redundant as “consensus” means general agreement. (See line 2 in the section, “Normal Behavior”. Sorry. I just can’t help myself….

    Like

    1. Hi Harry –
      Hmmm….. The OED defines consensus as “an agreement in opinion.” So, while some say adding “general” is redundant, others say it is not. The Cambridge English Dictionary actually uses “general consensus” as an example of usage in a sentence.

      Seems to me, there is not general consensus on the issue. 🙂 🙂

      Linda

      Like

  3. Thanks Linda, I love reading your posts. They’re always informative. My two are conspecific coprophagers (is that even a word?). My little girl taught my bigger boy. As long as they don’t lick me for the rest of the day, I’ve learned to live with it. And, and, I’m going to say this, even though the studies have disproved it: I recently switched my two pups to Just Food for Dogs, after reading one of your recent posts, because the thought that they might eat smaller poops from each other was an attractive one. And then something unexpected happened: they stopped eating each other’s poop. I know, I know, n=2 is not any sort of reportable results. But I can tell you that I’m pleased.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Karen, Thanks! Coprophagers….. I like it….Let’s go with that! 🙂 Your experience with switching foods is really interesting! I think my take on this is that while there are no data suggesting a consistent diet cause in terms of a nutrient deficiency or an abundance or lack of a particular type of ingredient, it seems altogether possible that individual dogs are attracted to the smell/taste of certain feces. Since food ingredients and food quality (in particular how digestible a food may be) definitely influence fecal quality and composition, then I would venture that your dogs’ poops changed significantly with the new food – and perhaps one of those changes changed the attractiveness of the poops to your dogs. Just speculation, but it certainly seems like a possibility. Regardless, we are never ones to look a gift non-poop-eater in the mouth, so definitely be pleased! Thanks for your note! Linda

      Like

  4. SIGH… and I thought your article would enlighten us with a magic cure (pineapple juice, unicorn dust, wizard elixir, shaman herbs… no?? Nothing??). Just kidding of course 🙃. I just wish I didn’t need to witness or smell it. My gag reflex would be happy to just lay dormant, but my Toller thinks gag reflexes are fun to elicit!! Thanks for your always entertaining and educational articles!!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Renelle! So sorry for the disappointment. Have you tried Unicorn scat? Dried and ground works best, I hear. 🙂 🙂 So, if I understand correctly, your Toller is a poop eater?? Oh dear. There goes a very cherished myth in my household. Stanley is our second Toller. Chippy (our first) was extremely fastidious and proper – he never had a speck of dirt on him and was horrified at the prospect of eating poop…… Stanley is almost as fussy….. So, with our “n of 2” we decided (obviously incorrectly) that Tollers were neat little guys who would never dream of becoming poop eaters. Thanks a lot for dispelling that fantasy….. 🙂 🙂 Thanks for posting (and for the laugh!). Linda

      Like

    1. Hi Andressa! Thank YOU for such a great piece of research! I so enjoyed reading your paper and learning about your work. Best of luck as you continue your research – I would love to write about your work again some time! Best, Linda

      Like

  5. Another great article! No one in our family engages in conspecific coprophagy, but some of us LOVE LOVE LOVE poop from other animals. Wombat poop is a particular treat and we eat it most days. We all assume it’s pretty good for us to get those extra pre-digested fibres. But it would be cool to know *exactly* what it is we are ingesting that is good for us. (No one in our family tries to dissuade us from eating poop of the various herbivores around here: the only rule is this – if you eat a lot of poop, don’t then lick the mamma’s face immediately afterwards).

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Kristie! Thanks! Wombat poop!!! The little cubes! Your dogs have discerning tastes for sure – only animal (I think) that poops cubes! Yes, one does wonder if there may be a fiber benefit to consuming wombat poop……I see a future study topic, for sure. Thanks for posting! Linda

      Like

Have a comment? Feel welcome to participate!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s